Judge weighs dismissal of Murdaugh charges

Posted

Less than five months before Alex Murdaugh’s retrial on the killings of his wife and younger son, his lawyers are asking the judge to go back to “square one.” 

This means dismissing the case and seeking renewed charges, based on the defense team’s allegation that the lead investigator purposely lied to the grand jury about evidence in the 2021 shooting deaths. 

Prosecutors counter that Murdaugh’s indictment should stand because any inaccurate statements by the investigator did not qualify as prosecutorial misconduct. Plus, they said, there were other pieces of evidence that supported the disgraced attorney’s murder and firearm charges in Colleton County.

After hearing arguments from both sides at the Lexington County courthouse on Friday, Nov. 13, presiding judge Debra McCaslin said she’d consider the issue for a few days before releasing a written decision. But she left the courtroom with cryptic parting words.

“If you had to go back to the grand jury, could you have it done and all ready to go April 5?” McCaslin asked the lead prosecutor, S.C. Deputy Attorney General Creighton Waters, referring to the new trial’s start date.

Waters responded affirmatively, saying: “I’m always working ahead.”

The Colleton County grand jury is scheduled to meet again on Dec. 10, according to Murdaugh’s team.

If the judge throws out Murdaugh’s indictment, it would be another twist to the high-profile Colleton County case. It’s heading to a Sumter County jury after the S.C. Supreme Court tossed Murdaugh’s convictions in May, ruling that a Colleton County court officer had made prejudicial statements to the jury while Murdaugh’s trial was taking place in 2023.

McCaslin has moved the retrial venue to the Midlands. She agreed with Murdaugh’s attorneys that he would not get a fair and impartial jury in the area where the killings occurred, since the potential jury pool has been oversaturated with news and information about the case.    

Murdaugh is serving time in a South Carolina prison for having stolen millions of dollars from his law firm’s clients. But he has denied killing his wife, Maggie, 52, and younger son Paul, 22, in the family’s Islandton estate on the night of June 7, 2021.

Defense attorneys are now training the spotlight on the T-shirt Murdaugh was wearing when law enforcement met him at the crime scene that evening, after he reported finding the two bodies.

Defense attorney Jim Griffin said Agent David Owen of the State Law Enforcement Division told the grand jury in 2022 that an expert had found Maggie’s and Paul’s blood spatter on Murdaugh’s T-shirt — which placed him at their shootings — even though SLED’s own lab found no such evidence on the shirt. 

“That puts his son's spattered blood when his brain ejects from his head on his shirt, and it's false. It’s fabricated,” Griffin said at the recent hearing as Murdaugh looked on, dressed in a dark suit and tie. “The grand jury was misled greatly when they returned this indictment.” 

The state-contracted expert initially found no blood spatter, Griffin said, but the man’s opinion changed after multiple discussions with SLED agents.

Owen earlier said he reviewed the 2021 SLED lab report only after appearing before the grand jury. Griffin described the agent’s behavior as “reckless.”      

The defense team also said Owen inaccurately told the grand jury that investigators found firearms on Murdaugh's property matching the ammunition used to kill Paul.

Waters, the lead prosecutor, acknowledged the inaccurate details but said the state’s overall evidence supported its decision to charge Murdaugh in the double homicide.

The state’s blood spatter expert, Waters said, stands by his final report that Murdaugh’s shirt contained over a hundred stains from blood spatter.

Judge McCaslin has repeatedly said Murdaugh’s new trial will take place in April and she will entertain no requests for a delay.

Tiffany Tan has been a journalist in the U.S. and abroad for more than 20 years. Contact her on Facebook at Reporter Tiffany Tan or 839-223-4652 on mobile/Signal/WhatsApp. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here