Parole again denied for Susan Smith, 32 years after she killed her 2 sons

Posted

COLUMBIA — Parole  has again been denied for Susan Smith, a mother convicted of murdering her two young sons in a case that garnered national attention more than three decades ago.

The state parole board voted unanimously Thursday, Nov. 19, with one member recusing herself: Geraldine Miro was a warden in the prison where Smith was originally housed.

On Oct. 25, 1994, Smith left her sons — 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex — buckled in their car seats and rolled her car into John D. Long Lake, located in South Carolina’s Upstate.

For nine days after, Smith claimed a Black man carjacked her and drove off with her sons. She tearfully pleaded on national television for their return, before eventually admitting to investigators what she had done.

“I want to say I’m sorry to Michael and Alex. They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die,” Smith told the board during her hearing. “I dropped to my lowest when I let that car go into that lake.”

Smith also apologized to her ex-husband, David Smith, who did not get to see his sons grow up.

“He didn’t get to see them ride a bike or go to school, and I’m really, really sorry for that,” she said. “I would go back and change all of that if I could.”

David Smith told the parole board her apology doesn’t change the grief he feels.

“Is 32 years enough for what she did?” he asked.

“She took away one of the greatest gifts God gives us – life. She did that deliberately. It wasn’t an accident, it wasn’t a mistake,” David Smith added. “And I know in my heart, granting her parole would be a huge injustice.”

Prosecutors sought the death penalty for Smith. The jury ultimately opted for life in prison.

But in 1995, when Smith was tried, a life sentence did not mean life. She could seek parole after 30 years.

Legislators changed the law the next year, making those with life sentences ineligible for parole.

Smith, who is now 55, made her first plea for parole in November 2024. The Nov. 19  hearing marked her second attempt. She has the option to reapply every two years.

That’s something state Speaker Pro Tem Tommy Pope, who was the chief prosecutor for Smith’s trial, hopes to change. He told the parole board he wants to introduce legislation that would extend the time between hearings to three to five years.

“I’m going to do everything possible to change that,” he said.

In South Carolina, the outcome of a parole hearing is almost always “no.”

In 2024, the Palmetto State granted parole at the lowest rate in the country — just 4% — when compared to other states that offer discretionary parole.

And data from the state Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services, which reports numbers quarterly, shows the board approved just 6% of the cases it heard between April and June. Of those denied, 71% were non-violent offenders.

In making the case for Smith’s release, her attorney, Tommy Thomas, blamed her actions in 1994 on a history of mental illness, which started as a 6-year-old after her father committed suicide and continued throughout her teen years due to sexual abuse by her stepfather.

Psychologist Jessie Hill told the board that Smith’s mental illness has been treated in prison with medication. Also aiding her mental health was the onset of menopause, which ended bouts of depression triggered by her menstrual cycle, as well as the deaths of her mother and stepfather.

But Pope warned the board against her release, saying the proliferation of social media would force David Smith and his family to relive the boys’ deaths.

“Back then, she relished the media attention, and I submit nothing’s changed in that regard,” Pope said. “If you think his family’s been through hell now, imagine every day, if you pick up your phone or you turn all your computer, and there’s Susan.

“There are people out there who idolize Susan. There are people that want to be with Susan. That’s how upside down this country has become,” he added. “She needs to stay where she’s at.”

The parole board has a list of official reasons it can cite for denying parole.

It cited two of them Tuesday, Nov. 17: risk posed to the community as well as seriousness of the crime and Smith’s attitude toward it.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here